What Does Money Really Have to do With it?
From an article by Jacqueline Ching, “’Low-income’ should not mean low expectations”. Many teachers have biases regarding low-income students, leading them to lower their expectations. I have seen many of my peers who come from low-income family’s loose motivation and confidence in school because of teachers who do not believe in them. This guides me to my question, what does money really have to do with it?
In the many years I have been in school, I have moved from low-income to high-income areas and I can see a difference regarding teachers and students. In high-income areas, teachers have high expectations because they believe these are the students who will become doctors and engineers. But in the low-income schools, teachers have set their expectations extremely low. Teachers may believe that low-income students are bound to fail in school and in life. But according to the article by Jacqueline Ching, this is not the case.
When students are set up for success, they succeed and when they are set up for failure, they fail. We as teachers are the ones who set this standard for our students. So why don’t we set all students up for success, not just the high-income ones? Well, we do this because we have this bias that our high-income students are more important, and they deserve to succeed. When in my experience, I have seen that low-income students are the ones who deserve recognition. In conclusion, by setting up our low-income students for success, they will succeed.
Resources:


Hi Schuyler! I really liked reading your blog post this week! I also read the article "Low income should not mean low expectations" by Jacqueline Ching and read some interesting things. I had experiences in both low-income and high-income schools and there was a big difference. Teachers at one school would be teaching the bare minimum while teacher at the other school would hold after school tutorials and would constantly tell students to get help if they were struggling. I liked the point you brought up from the article about if you are set up for success then you can succeed. Do you think teachers may be more involved with their students if they are getting paid more?
ReplyDeleteHi Maya! I found the question you brought up interesting! I think teachers should be as involved as possible no matter how they are being paid. I know it is easier said than done and many teachers feel like they should just do what they are getting paid for, and I understand that. If teachers do start to be paid more, I think they should feel as though they should be involved more!
DeleteHi Schuyler! Your blog was so interesting, I feel like I could relate to it so much! I also saw a lot of kids on my classes who were from low income areas who lost motivation for school because our teachers weren't pouring into them. Those are the students that teachers should be really trying to pour into and also create a relationship with. I completely agree with how you say when students are set up to fail, they will fail. As teachers we need to set aside our bias' aside and focus in the success of our students. I know for me personally this is something I really want to take with me in my classroom because as a society I think we need to move in this direction. Do you think that the most change needs to happen in schools that have more low income students? or do we need to focus on the low income students in high income areas? I think we should focus on both, but I feel like the low income students in the high income areas really get set up for failure because they are so overlooked. Change can really start with us as teachers, so the way we set our students up for success can really do a lot.
ReplyDeleteHi Katie! Your question really made me think. I have never thought to separate low-income schools and low-income students in high-income areas. I think your point of focusing more on low-income students in high-income areas is very important. These students are being left behind from the majority, but the students in low-income schools are all being left behind from the majority of society. This is something that really made me think!
DeleteHi Schuyler! I found your blog post so interesting, I could completely understand how school in higher and lower income don't have the same expectations because they assume that kids who come from lower income families won't strive to do anything else and won't try to do better. Though that is completely wrong because the people who come from lower incomes work the hardest to make their lives for them and their families better but i am excited to see how you choose to change that and how many other choose to change it. I feel one thing i would love to see in your blog to is how you will personally change it in your classroom and in the teaching world. I really can see how high income families and students are seen as high priority because they go to more higher income schools and are from richer families and i believe they should treat all schools equally and with respect and with the same expectations for everyone.
ReplyDeleteHi Aaliyah! I love that you brought up that the misconception that low-income students don't work! These students truly work the hardest because they are given so much less to work with than high-income students. I have thought of many ways to change these misconceptions in my classroom, but I think I will have to see what I am given once I start teaching!
DeleteFantastic blog Schuyler! Its actually important and great that you got to experience living in areas with low and high income as you saw how teachers approached and treated these students. Now that you have this, how would you learn from this experience to ensure that your classroom and students are treated with respect and set up for success. Other people have not experienced living in both financial areas which may lead to more bias and stereotypes. Just because one lives in a low income area does not mean one will fail and same goes for high income areas doesn't mean that they'll succeed. Teachers have no right to mistreat and have these different expectations based on students financial situations because at the end of the day its out of the students control. They need to stop focusing on what they cant control and focus on what they can control like being anti-bias and having the same expectations for everyone. According to Aliyyas Swaby article , though "low income students are receiving 20% additional monies" , they may need more thing that money can not simply buy like anti-bias teachers and environments where one is not judged based on their background and financial situations.
ReplyDeleteHi Schuyler! I really loved reading your blog and your opinions were very interesting and definitely put things into a different light for me! I completely agree with your statement that schools are very different in low income versus high income schools and how this effects students. I agree that often the kids who come from these low places often succeed the most with the amount of work and effort they are willing to put in to grow and make better lives for themselves. I love how you used the article to further support your thoughts and that article was very interesting and made me learn a lot of things I didn’t know. I feel like us as students who have seen many different things are the best people to make these changes and stop the labeling of students solely based on where they come from and not their true potential.
ReplyDeleteHello Schulyer I really enjoyed reading your blog for this week because it addresses many important issues that need to be brought to light. We have some of the same experiences but also very different. I too have went to high income and low income schools also. My high income school was very diverse and had great resources for the students to succeed. But it was here that I saw teachers put stereotypes on the students who didn’t have a lot. But at my low income school it was a charter school we didn’t have a lot of resources, and it wasn’t in the best community. But most of the teachers there cared about the students and wanted them to succeed. It was mostly minorities at the school and the teachers looked like the students, so I believed thats why eventhough we didn’t have a lot of resources the teachers made up for it with their caring and thoughtfulness.
ReplyDeleteHi Schuyler! You could not have explained this any better. I liked your explanation on how teachers view their students differently based on if they come from high income or low income. And this really does not sit right with me at all. This gives me that "stereotype" vibe. Teachers thinking that if a student comes from low income they will not be as successful as those who come from high income. Its like saying that black students will not succeed like white students will. At the end of the day, none of this should even matter. A teacher should know their role. They are a teacher and a role model, as well as their students biggest support system inside the classroom. A teacher should WANT to see their students succeed no matter what the case may be. How is it fair to the students to go to school and not get their teachers support?They should be able to attend school KNOWING they are being supported and are being led to success, not failure.
ReplyDelete